Scott Coogan is the star football player at Beecher Falls High at the start of the series. Kate has a crush on him and casts the "Come to Me Love Spell" to catch his attention. It works and he asks her to the Valentine's dance. After the Three break the spell, he remains interested in Kate and they continue dating. He gives up a full scholarship in New York to stay near Beecher Falls to be with Kate. However, Kate had fallen for Tyler Decklin and they break up soon after.
During the Midsummer celebration in In the Dreaming, Kate runs across him in the woods and he kisses her. She considers getting back together with him, but she ultimately chooses Tyler.